Would you like your great-grandchild to be a robot?

Published January 14, 2018 by Nan Mykel

From Edward O. Wilson’s Consilience: “Thanks to advances  of genetics and molecular biology underway, hereditary change will soon depend less on natural selection than on social choice….The prospect of this ‘volitional evoltion’ –a species deciding what to do about its own heredity–will present the most profound intellectual and ethical choices humanity has ever faced….humanity will be positioned god-like to take control of its own ultimate fate. It can, if it chooses,  alter not just the anatomy and intelligence of the species, but also the emotions and creative drive that compose the very core of human nature.(p. 299-300)

Other than the repair of disabling defects, they will resist hereditary change.  They will do so in order to save the emotions and epigenetic rules of mental development. , because these elements compose the physical soul of the species. The reasoning is as follows: Alter the emotions and and epigenetic rules enough , and some people might seem “better,” but they would no longer be human. Neutralize the elements of human nature in favor of  pure rationality, and the result wold be badly constructed, protein-based computers. Why should a species give up the defining core of its existence, built by millions of years of biological  trial and error? (p 303)

Wikipedia tells us that “Throughout history, it has been frequently assumed that robots will one day be able to mimic human behavior and manage tasks in a human-like fashion. Todayrobotics is a rapidly growing field, as technological advances continue; researching, designing, and building new robots serve various practical purposes, whether …

The ambition of modern robotics goes beyond copying humans, beyond the effort to make walking,talking androids that are indistinguishable from people. Future robots will have superhumanabilities in both the physical and digital realms.  From pr for new book.

Thre’s discussion about making a robot that can be your friend…It’s been pointed out that sex robotics would free up a lot of time taken for dating, but spare time won’t be a problem, due to jobs being replaced by robots.  Do any followers of this blog have thoughts about robots?

2 comments on “Would you like your great-grandchild to be a robot?

  • Explanations we come up with are not complete explanations and sometimes our explanations get in the way of better ones. I don’t think computers are a good explanation for who we we. They have no ability to make choices and they reason better than rationalize. We have a limited ability to choose which makes us motivated reasoners or rationalizers. That’s why we have goals and sometimes even get things done. Robots are best seen as tools to help us not as something we will ever become. There is more potential for change in looking at the genetic explanation of who we are, but genes are more what keep us human rather than how we could evolve into something not human. From a Darwinian perspective I think “punctuated equilibrium” rather than “phyletic gradualism” best explains how species behave but even that explanation is partial. So I’m not really worried about biological engineering either. The best cure for some of the diseases we have (Alzheimers, auto-immune diseases, diabetes) is diet and lifestyle changes and avoiding environmental toxins rather than genetic engineering. Just my current perspective on complicated and controversial topics.


    • I’m primarily concerned about the loss of the ability to love and empathize. And look at all the aggression, kin preference and survival of the fittest flowing through our veins that we already try to overcome! It is anticipated that robots will be smarter than us. Why would they want to keep us around? Additional thoughts welcome. Thanks for sharing and say more about better explanations.


  • Please share your own experiences here...

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

    WordPress.com Logo

    You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

    Google photo

    You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

    Connecting to %s

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


    Be kind to yourself and others.

    Walking the Rails

    Basking in the Triumphs and Frustrations of a Disability

    Yolanda - "Det här är mitt privata krig"

    Kreativ text, annorlundaskap, poesi, bipolaritet, Aspergers syndrom, fotografi


    Poetry of a changing Earth. The grief is real--so is the hope.


    Spouse trainer, motherhood survivalist, bread enthusiast... overall great person.


    Take a few minutes to slow down and think about what's going on in your world...


    Own That Domain Today


    "Traveling and Retired"

    About the Jez of It

    Poetry, stories and strange odds and ends from the desk of a writer

    Athens Writers Association

    Bringing passionate genius to the foreground in Athens, GA -- 2013-2019


    Seeking Dialogue to Inform, Enlighten, and/or Amuse You and Me


    Tigers not daughters

    Nature Is My Therapy

    Building meaningful and joyful connections to nature

    By Hook Or By Book

    Book Reviews, News, and Other Stuff


    My writings of fiction, essay, poetry, observation & commentary

    Intellectual Shaman

    Poetry for Finding Meaning in the Madness

    %d bloggers like this: