Dialogue: Poet to Poet

Published June 30, 2017 by Nan Mykel

“I guess I have been holding back some of my resentment. I’m in a  nice normal poetry group on the outside and they love to laugh at my funny lines. This isn’t a therapy group–far from it. It’s a nice civilized friendly group, and I sure can’t let the cat (me) out of the bag there.”  The above was posted on June 25, 2017 under Could I Re-Write My Childhood?

The above is kinda setting the stage for the following dialogue. Because P1 and P2 is boring, I’m calling the participants Me and You. but don’t take it personally.  Remember, “You” equals P2.

Me: I’m puzzled and frustrated by poetry sharing in my blog family.

You: You only post on your own blog and d’verse.

Me:  Yeah, and I’m puzzled by that.  I didn’t understand, and I recall giving advice on grieving, not realizing it was probably  just a poem, not reality.

You:  You were just a newbie, you didn’t know any better.

Me: I don’t have that excuse any more.  I think it’s wonderful how most people praise each other’s efforts/poetry on d’verse.

You: Me too!

Me: But I have two general questions. Sometimes we  respond to content (“I’ve had that experience too, in Florida…); sometimes we respond to the poetry form and metaphors; and sometimes we respond to the emotions which we resonate to. I guess the foregoing is not a question, just an insecurity about which is preferred.

You: So you do want to do the right, preferred thing?

Me: Well…yeah…I guess.

You: Okay, what is your next question or insecurity?

Me: Is the purpose of d’verse to make readers  happy?  I’m not saying it right–moved, enlightened, thankful, appreciative of life?

You: Sounds like a worthy purpose to me. I don’t like whining posts.

Me: Me neither,  but when I attempt to write poetry I’m starting to feel a “should,” like I should write for its impact on readers, like I should brighten their day instead of “let the cat out of the bag,” that I’m feeling hurt, pain, jealous, vengeful, despair, unloved, rejected, cynical, bruised, hopeless, etc.  (Not that I feel like that often, mind you).

You: d’verse isn’t a place for therapy, you know. There’s a  survivor’s blog somewhere out there for survivors,

Me: But not a poetry blog for survivors.  I guess I’m unclear about the difference between whiners and grieving and non-believers and reality.

You:  If you’re not feeling love and thankfulness and joy,  you don’t have to write a poem, you know.

Me: I’m already feeling misunderstood. I think I’ve been guilty of “arguing back” with some poets myself, instead of just accepting their words.  And I do remember that the best gift you can give is to hear and accept.   I remember Carl Rogers now and how precious it is to just be really heard.

You: You do realize that now you’ve made anyone who comments on your work self-conscious?

Me:  Oh, I’m sorry!

You: I should think so!

LESSON FOR TODAY:  People are just people and really accepting them means just letting them do their thing and follow their creative impulses.  So there’s no other message from this  navel-gazing post.

5 comments on “Dialogue: Poet to Poet

  • There are actually a lot of survivor blogs where the authors post poetry and the back-and-forth conversation is about the painful content. They would probably be the perfect audience for poems about jealousy, rage, despair or any other emotion. Of course, you don’t need to write for any audience at all (as you well know!), but I think we all like to get responses from people who can relate to what we’ve posted. So I just wanted to suggest that you focus some of your poems in that direction. ????

    Like

  • Please share your own experiences here...

    Scottie's Playtime

    Come see what I share

    Chronicles of an Anglo Swiss

    Welcome to the Anglo Swiss World

    ChatterLei

    EXPRESSIONS

    Anthony’s Crazy Love and Life Lessons in Empathy

    Loves, lamentation, and life through prose, stories, passions, and essays.

    The Life-long Education Blog

    Let's Explore The Great Mystery Together!

    Ned Hamson's Second Line View of the News

    Second Look Behind the Headlines - News you can use...

    Evolution of Medical profession-Extinction of good doctors

    choosing medical career; problem faced by doctors; drawbacks of medical profession;patient tutorials

    Petchary's Blog

    Cries from Jamaica

    Memoirs of Madness

    A place where I post unscripted, unedited, soulless rants of a insomniac madman

    Life Matters

    CHOOSE LOVE

    Mybookworld24

    My Life And Everything Within It

    Mitch Reynolds

    Just Here Secretly Figuring Out My Gender

    Frank J. Peter

    A Watering Hole for Freelance Human Beings Who Still Give a Damn

    Passionate about making a difference

    "The only thing that stands between you and your dream is the will to try and the belief that it is actually possible." - Joel Brown

    Yip Abides

    we're all cyborgs now

    annieasksyou...

    Seeking Dialogue to Inform, Enlighten, and/or Amuse You and Me